2023 MTC Softball All-Conference Team
| Place | Player Name | School | Points |
| 1st – MVP | Olivia Tipton | Waltonville | 113 |
| 2nd – Tie | Trista Moore | OPS | 98 |
| 2nd – Tie | Morgan Hance | Clay City | 98 |
| 4th | Jacy Knox | Woodlawn | 71 |
| 5th | Emma Williamson | CORL | 69 |
| 6th | AJ Long | Waltonville | 68 |
| 7th | Kodie VanEycke | Woodlawn | 66 |
| 8th | Hailey Lane | OPS | 65 |
| 9th | Kenzie Seddon | Waltonville | 58 |
| 10th | Addi Tate | Grayville | 54 |
| 11th | Lauren Robb | OPS | 53 |
| 12th | Drayton Mosberger | Grayville | 36 |
| 13th | Ali Downs | Woodlawn | 35 |
| 14th | Macey Spicer | OPS | 25 |
| 15th | Kylie Nalewajka | CORL | 21 |
Coach of the Year – Shawn Rasul, Odin (4 votes)
2023 MTC All-Conference Honorable Mentions
| Place | Player Name | School | Points |
| 1st – tie | Bria Williams | Waltonville | 19 |
| 1st – tie | Payton Knight | Webber | 19 |
| 3rd | Ella Bequetta | Woodlawn | 17 |
| 4th | Hanna Utlaut | Waltonville | 14 |
| 5th | Rhea Rollinson | OPS | 13 |
| 6th | Gracie Barber | Clay City | 12 |
| 7th – tie | Avery England | Woodlawn | 11 |
| 7th – tie | Emma Hedrick | Cisne | 11 |
Other receiving votes:
- Kennedi Odum, Woodlawn (10)
- Khloe King, Webber (8)
- Josie Greenwalt, Wayne City (7)
- Chelsea Beck, Clay City (5)
- Kenna Anselment, Wayne City (2)
- Abigail Biggs, Cisne (1)
- Reese Laur, Waltonville (1)
